Redskins/Browns Trade (denied)

Redskins Trade:
WR Anthony Armstrong 77 overall 28 years old B pot 2 years at 16 points
HB Ryan Torain 76 overall 24 years old B pot 2 years at 17 points
1st Round pick

Browns Trade:
HB Peyton Hillis 91 overall 26 years old A pot 4 years at 25 points
WR Brian Robiskie 70 overall 23 years old B pot 1 year at 11 points

Redskins have 176 points free before trade
173 left free after

Browns have 168 points free before trade
171 left after

Looks like a good trade. I approve.

Only reason I can see Browns making this deal is to rebuild. But to rebuild by trading away your best young player? I don't get it. Last year when I was the only person approving trades this would be shot down in a heartbeat. I dissaprove.

I have given this trade a lot of thought and I think the Redskins have to give up more. The Browns are trading two of their best young offensive players, including their best overall player. Also, the best player the Redskins are giving back is a 77 which is only 7 points higher than the worst guy they are getting back. Further, the Browns are getting no A potential guys back. I don't think the 1st round pick is enough here to offset the difference. Denied for now.

I really need to see the Browns owner's reasoning behind this trade. Plus he has to agree to it in the first place.

I will contact the browns owner and work on the deal

When I originally made the deal I thought WR Armstrong [a pot] was younger. When I saw he was 28 I mentioned it to the Skins owner but gave it a go anyways. I figured it would be denied based on the fact that he was getting young a's while giving an older a up. only other people i would be interested in is kerrigan or williams the LT, otherwise I guess I'll hold off

WR Armstrong is actually A potential not B potential as originally listed.

Yea, I thought he was a B lol

With Armstrong being A potential that sways my opinion some. If you took out Robiske or added another late round pick or player because Armstrong is a bit older, then i would approve.

I think I'm just gonna stay with what I got for now, second thoughts I guess.

yeah, i hear that. you have a solid running game as is anyway. 4 capable backs to work with that all do different things. I would be using Helu the most anyway, hes nice! Actually I want him and McIntosh and Wilson...